[Mpi3-tools] MPI_T - Reviews and Question on Initialization

Marty Itzkowitz marty.itzkowitz at oracle.com
Thu Jun 30 09:14:53 CDT 2011

On 6/30/11 7:08 AM, Dave Goodell wrote:
> On Jun 30, 2011, at 3:22 AM CDT, Martin Schulz wrote:
>> Here is Bronis's comment:
>> The advice to users on page 39 is not just advice to users.
>> The problem is that I do not see anywhere that requires inheritance
>> of the tool information interface state. You only mention it in this
>> advice to users, which is non-normative. You need a normative statement
>> that it is inherited.
>> I know we wanted to be careful when we wrote that part, but
>> I kind of agree with Bronis, that this should be stronger. Would
>> it be OK to just drop the "advice" environment, i.e., make the
>> text that is now an advice to a regular part of the document?
> Works for me.  That was a good catch, Bronis.

I agree.


More information about the mpiwg-tools mailing list