[Mpi-22] Another MPI-2.2 attribute ambiguity?

[Supalov, Alexander]

Hi,

Intel MPI (and most likely other MPICH2 derivatives) appears to use method #2.

Best regards.

Alexander 

-----Original Message-----
From: Jeff Squyres [mailto:jsquyres_at_[hidden]] 
Sent: Thursday, April 16, 2009 4:19 PM
To: MPI 2.2; Rajeev Thakur; William Gropp; Rolf Rabenseifner; Hubert Ritzdorf; Terry Dontje; Dave Goodell; Darius Buntinas; Pavan Balaji; Supalov, Alexander; Bronis de Supinski; David Solt; Hans Westgaard Ry; Håkon Bugge
Subject: Another MPI-2.2 attribute ambiguity?

This is related to -- but different from -- MPI 2.2 ticket #55  
("MPI-2.1 Cross-language attribute example is wrong").  Explicitly  
adding all the #55 CC members to this mail, plus a few others.

I cannot find any text in MPI-2.1 (e.g., p223-225) describing specific  
behavior regarding the EXTRA_STATE arguments passed to the Fortran  
keyval copy and delete functions (both the ADDRESS_KIND and deprecated  
flavors).  I see two choices:

1. pass the user's original EXTRA_STATE argument by reference to the  
callbacks, or
2. copy the user's original EXTRA_STATE into internal MPI storage and  
pass *that* value by reference to the callbacks

==> Open MPI currently does #1.  What do other implementations do?

I raise this issue because the text does not indicate which way is  
right.  And I just ran across an old Sun test that assumed #2.  But  
our internal copy of the Intel MPI tests assume #1 (to be fair: I have  
no idea if the Intel tests originally assumed #2 and we changed them  
to #1 over time).  Indeed, #2 is actually in-line with the philosophy  
of storing attribute values in internal MPI storage.  E.g.:

   INTEGER foo = 4
   INTEGER bar
   CALL MPI_COMM_SET_ATTR(comm, keyval, foo, ierr)
   foo = 5
   CALL MPI_COMM_GET_ATTR(comm, keyval, bar, flag, ierr)

bar should equal 4, not 5 (right?).

So what does that mean (or imply) about the EXTRA_STATE value passed  
to the Fortran callbacks?


-- 
Jeff Squyres
Cisco Systems
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Intel GmbH
Dornacher Strasse 1
85622 Feldkirchen/Muenchen Germany
Sitz der Gesellschaft: Feldkirchen bei Muenchen
Geschaeftsfuehrer: Douglas Lusk, Peter Gleissner, Hannes Schwaderer
Registergericht: Muenchen HRB 47456 Ust.-IdNr.
VAT Registration No.: DE129385895
Citibank Frankfurt (BLZ 502 109 00) 600119052
This e-mail and any attachments may contain confidential material for
the sole use of the intended recipient(s). Any review or distribution
by others is strictly prohibited. If you are not the intended
recipient, please contact the sender and delete all copies.